[TriggerMan]

Originally Posted by Saquist

What he ...wanted can not be accurately be determined from what he did not do.

Or proposed, or talked about...

Oh...yes...I know what you're saying.
I also know what you're avoiding.

You don't.

Gene Roddenberry helped to write Encounter at Farpoint. He only had authority over the 1st season,

And the second.

there was a strike that stopped his participation in the 2nd season

How would it have?

[Saquist]

Originally Posted by TriggerMan

Or proposed, or talked about...

I can see deductive reason is well out side your skill set.
So we can't draw conclusion about what he wanted from what he proposed or talked about? How about what he wrote? No?

I think you're just talking to talking at this point.

You don't.

Your above statement clashes with that declaration.

And the second.

Not full control

How would it have?

For the same reason the writers strike of 2007 and 2008 delayed Star Trek from coming out on time. He was part of the Writers Guild of America.

[TriggerMan]

Originally Posted by Saquist

I can see deductive reason is well out side your skill set.

We can deduce from the fact that Roddenberry never talked about, proposed, nor produced WW3 stories that he wasn't particularly interested in doing one. There's nothing more you need to discuss on the subject.

So we can't draw conclusion about what he wanted from what he proposed or talked about? How about what he wrote? No?

You didn't get what I was saying.

I think you're just talking to talking at this point.

I'm talking to talking???

Not full control

Would have been the same amount of participation until Season 3.

For the same reason the writers strike of 2007 and 2008 delayed Star Trek from coming out on time.

Not directly.

He was part of the Writers Guild of America.

It would only stop him from writing new scripts (which he wasn't doing anyway outside of one episode,) not from serving in his executive producer's role. His participation remained unchanged.

[kevin]

Originally Posted by TriggerMan

We can deduce from the fact that Roddenberry never talked about, proposed, nor produced WW3 stories that he wasn't particularly interested in doing one.

Exactly.

[starwarsrcks]

Well I want more character development, a good solid story do you think so

[Saquist]

Originally Posted by TriggerMan

We can deduce from the fact that Roddenberry never talked about, proposed, nor produced WW3 stories that he wasn't particularly interested in doing one.

That is true you can deduce that.
Roddenberry avoided the war angle.
THAT would be a stronger more logical deduction with a longer pattern of recurrence.

Once again...
I am forced to make someone's argument more logical when they cannot.
I can't help myself. You could argue from knowledge and logic but you chose a meandering route to get there. It's like you choosing the window when the door is unlocked.

I waited...
But you never figured it out. Do you ever error check yourself just to make sure your argument is sound? You chose the most flimsy of arguments to stand behind.

You didn't get what I was saying.

No, Trigger...
You didn't explain what you were saying. There is big difference.

I'm talking to talking???

Correction.
Talking to BE talking.

Would have been the same amount of participation until Season 3.

I said control.
You said participation.

The subject is "Gene Roddenberry's desire, motive or inclination to go further into the World War III scenario he created. You provided the erroneous rebuttal that his death had little to do with his inaction to that objective.

He gave up control on season two. So...no. Not the same participation. You're 0/2.

Not directly.

I don't know that.

It would only stop him from writing new scripts (which he wasn't doing anyway outside of one episode,) not from serving in his executive producer's role. His participation remained unchanged.

If that's true then why did he give up control of the second season if all he couldn't do was write?

[Dominus of Megadeus]

I'd like to see Spock and Uhura in the mess hall, late when every one is asleep, making pancakes.

[TriggerMan]

Originally Posted by Saquist

That is true you can deduce that.
Roddenberry avoided the war angle.
THAT would be a stronger more logical deduction with a longer pattern of recurrence.

Right, which is why his death doesn't change the fact that he didn't want to, and the fact its seldom if ever brought is up is why no one else wants to do a WW3 story either.

Blah, blah, blah

Right.

No, Trigger...
You didn't explain what you were saying. There is big difference.

Not my problem, you shoulda figured it out.

I said control.
You said participation.

Your quote:
http://www.startrekmovie.com/forums/...6&postcount=90

"there was a strike that stopped his participation in the 2nd season"

The subject is "Gene Roddenberry's desire, motive or inclination to go further into the World War III scenario he created. You provided the erroneous rebuttal that his death had little to do with his inaction to that objective.

Right, because as he was alive he never wanted to do it. How you can refute that?

He gave up control on season two. So...no. Not the same participation. You're 0/2.

If that's true then why did he give up control of the second season if all he couldn't do was write?

Ask Wiki, where you're copying and pasting your uncited information from.

[Dominus of Megadeus]

Another thing I'd like to see:

Captain Kirk: "...I'm going down there. Bones, Spock, Bob; You're with me."
Ensign Bob: "Huh?"
Kirk: "Is there a problem?"
Bob: "Uh, can't Uhura go down?"
Kirk: "Ensign, Uhura is needed on communications, and I don't remember ever asking for your advice on away team assembly. Now, let's go."
Bob: "I just had this shirt dry cleaned."
Kirk looks incredulously at the ensign, strip of light across his face, TOS style.
Bob: "Now, dang it! I know I'm going to get in trouble, but look at me. LOOK AT ME! I'm wearing a RED SHIRT! I may have born AT NIGHT, but I wasn't born LAST NIGHT!"
Spock gives Bob the Vulcan Nerve Pinch.
Kirk: "Thanks, Spock. Cupcake, take Ensign Bob to Transporter Room 4."
Security Officer: (Sigh) "Aye, sir."
Cupcake mutters, "If he calls me cupcake one more time..."
KirK: "By the way...You're on the away team, too."
Cupcake: "Huh???"

[NCC_1701A]

Originally Posted by Dominus of Megadeus

Another thing I'd like to see:

Captain Kirk: "...I'm going down there. Bones, Spock, Bob; You're with me."
Ensign Bob: "Huh?"
Kirk: "Is there a problem?"
Bob: "Uh, can't Uhura go down?"
Kirk: "Ensign, Uhura is needed on communications, and I don't remember ever asking for your advice on away team assembly. Now, let's go."
Bob: "I just had this shirt dry cleaned."
Kirk looks incredulously at the ensign, strip of light across his face, TOS style.
Bob: "Now, dang it! I know I'm going to get in trouble, but look at me. LOOK AT ME! I'm wearing a RED SHIRT! I may have born AT NIGHT, but I wasn't born LAST NIGHT!"
Spock gives Bob the Vulcan Nerve Pinch.
Kirk: "Thanks, Spock. Cupcake, take Ensign Bob to Transporter Room 4."
Security Officer: (Sigh) "Aye, sir."
Cupcake mutters, "If he calls me cupcake one more time..."
KirK: "By the way...You're on the away team, too."
Cupcake: "Huh???"