Originally Posted by starwarsrcks
Sorry if you don't like it
I like it. Don't know why he doesn't.
My favorite has evolved over time to become Quinto's Spock, followed by Pine, followed by Urban. I know everyone was floored by Urban (so was I at first) but after my 3rd viewing he seemed like an imitation rather than a re-characterization; and of the three, the most difficult one to get right is Spock.
I didn't get the subtly of Quinto's performance until the 3rd viewing (IMAX is kind of overwhelming... lol), however when I was no longer overwhelmed by everything else, he tore me to pieces with his suffering.