Did the new Star Trek movie have a sence of Remake to Star Trek: The Motion Picture?
 

I don't see it that way. Nods to TMP, perhaps, but I didn't get a sense of a remake.

Yeah , I can see the resemblance
They are both so incredible fast paced

:lol::lol:

No kidding; almost got whiplash from those endless scenes of cruising through the cloud....then the alien ship....then.....:001_tongue:

That bit of silliness aside, I really see no likeness between the Narada
and V'ger.
Or anything else between the two films, really.
As stated earlier, small....very small nods perhaps; nothing more.

I can see some of the similar plot devices...however, I've never considered TMP a remake. (Yes, yes, I know why some folks call it that...)

With the new film's Prime and it's own timelines...this film isn't a mere remake either, but it's closer to my concept of a remake than TMP is.

I do agree that XI follows a similar plot, but only in a loose sense.

I wouldn't call it a remake though.

TMP and Trek XI are night and day... I think the only homage scene that I would consider is the shot where Kirk and McCoy see the Big E in space.

Superficially, yes. A lightning storm in space. For me, TMP is the penultimate Trek film, I watched it again after seeing Star Trek (2009). I didn't feel they were similar at all. TMP was much deeper, it felt like 'classic' Trek, but for the big screen. Star Trek (2009) didn't have the same feel to it, it felt more like a fast-moving roller coaster ride. Star Trek (2009) actually borrows from several films, not just TMP, someone noted the similarities with Nemesis, also the torture scene with Captain Pike reminds one of the torture scene in TWOK.

What did you think of Star Trek the motion picture

So in fact Vger was a Romulan who wanted revenge instead of becoming one with God?